Super User
Admin
Starting with the completion of the 2018 AAL season, fans, coaches and league executives will be selecting 1st and 2nd team American Arena League All-League Selections each year.
2018 American Arena League All-League Selections
Offense
| Team | Quarterback |
| Atlanta Havoc | Lee Chapple |
| Cape Fear Heroes | Daryl Clark |
| Carolina Energy | David Washinton (Tie) |
| Georgia Doom | Luke Collis |
| New Jersey Flight | Stephen Panasuk (Tie) |
| Team | Receivers |
| Atlanta Havoc | Thyron Lewis |
| Atlanta Havoc | Ryan McDaniel |
| Cape Fear Heroes | Chad Walcott |
| Georgia Doom | Larry Beavers |
| Georgia Doom | Antwon Cuttis |
| Richmond Roughriders | Rashaad Carter |
| Team | Running Back |
| Cape Fear Heroes | Jaques Alston |
| Carolina Energy | Josh Doster |
| Team | Offensive Line |
| Atlanta Havoc | Tyshon Henderson |
| Cape Fear Heroes /East Carolina Torch | Tyson Fernandez |
| Carolina Energy | De'Quann Murray |
| Richmond Roughriders | James Carter |
| Richmond Roughriders | David Griffin |
| Richmond Roughriders | JB Walton |
| Team | Kick Returner |
| Atlanta Havoc | Martel Moore |
| Cape Fear Heroes | Jacques Alston |
| Team | Offensive Most Valuable Player of Year |
| Atlanta Havoc | Thyron Lewis |
2018 American Arena League All-League Selections
Defense
| Team | Defensive Back |
| Atlanta Havoc | Micheaux Robinson |
| Atlanta Havoc | Laroche Jackson |
| Carolina Energy | Cameron Sullivan |
| Carolina Energy | Majique Key |
| Florida Tarpons | Chris Smith |
| New Jersey Flight | Greg Jones |
| Team | Linebacker |
| Atlanta Havoc | Zack Brown |
| Cape Fear Heroes | Ralph Scott |
| Cape Fear Heroes | Jerimaih Spicer |
| Richmond Roughriders | Malique Johnson |
| Team | Defensive Line |
| Atlanta Havoc | Larry Ford |
| Cape Fear Heroes/ East Carolina Torch | Micah Robinson (DE) |
| Florida Tarpons | Dasmine Cathey |
| Richmond Roughriders | Keonte Hollis |
| Richmond Roughriders | Greg Hardy |
| Richmond Roughriders | Eddie Johnson |
| Team | Kicker |
| Atlanta Havoc | Jed Soloman |
| Richmond Roughriders | TC Stevens |
| Team | Defensive Most Valuable Player of Year |
| Atlanta Havoc | Larry Ford (Tie) |
| Richmond Roughriders | Keontae Hollis (Tie) |
